Fresh & Delicious

Fast & Easy Ordering

Finest Handcrafted Pizza

1835 M-139, Benton Harbor, MI 49022 (269) 925-1188

Our Story

We're blending our passion for making delicious food with our extensive knowledge of our cuisine to create authentic and classic dishes for your enjoyment. We use the freshest, locally-sourced ingredients and promise to give your taste buds something to be excited about.

Thank you for ordering directly from our website which helps us to provide the best service with a focus on top-quality ingredients. Enjoy your next meal to go—you will not be disappointed!

Special Offers

Call Us for Special Offers or to Place your Order.

Google Reviews

Charlie Brown

Yummy! Nice and unique peppery pepperoni pizza. I loved the bread part that was little sweet and chewy. Customer service was great too.

Nikita Weldy

Man I almost passed this little gem because of the poor comments. But I said naaaa let me se and im glade I did. Best wings in town I'd say. The bourbon Kentucky wings and the garlic parm wings are amazing the pizza was very good. It was a bit costly but it was very good.

David Proctor

If you love pizza, do yourself a favor drop what your doing. Immediately go here!! Home made dough, fresh ingredients, generously applied I might add. Excellent hand made sandwiches too. Are you still reading!! Stop!! Go get you some Joey C's!!

iam GhOsT

I'm never going pizza hut or dominos again after just one bite of the pepperoni pizza... And was better than you know who's extramostbestest. Also got a chicken bacon ranch pizza also... I'm not a huge fan of onions but wow very flavorful

Jon Bendewald

Joey C's is hands up n hands down the best pizza in Southwest Michigan. Fresh ingredients with secrets from Sicily...a seriously good pie!

Danielle Buhrfiend

One of the best pizzas around. The family has been making pizzas longer I have been alive and they know how to make a good pie. Always the best ratio of sauce to cheese and crust. You must go and eat their pizza. The biggest diamond you will find hidden in Benton Harbor.